S. Worthen (owlfish) wrote,
S. Worthen
owlfish

Book memory

I never read War and Peace. Other people have, and still others may falsely claim to have, but I won't even pretend. I haven't read it. While I often think about books I haven't read, this particular book I haven't read has been on my mind lately thanks to a recent BBC New Magazine series on bluffing about what one has read.

To prove how effective bluffing about a book-reading experience can be, the series presented a conversation between the author of a guide to book bluffing and a literature professor. The conversation was presented without speakers listed - it was up to the voting audience to guess whether speaker A or B was the one bluffing about the book.

Now in this instance, although it doesn't say so, I presume that the literature professor - who has indeed read War and Peace - read the book vaguely recently - or has at least taught it again somewhat recently. Some people have a very sticky memory for everything they've read. I'm not one of them, however.

I've read many books in my life, including ones I know I have forgotten. Sometimes, the title alone isn't enough of a prompt for my memory, but the blurb is. I've occasionally realized halfway through reading a book that I've read it before.

I have specific examples of books I've forgotten. In fourth grade, I read all of the Newbery award-winning books that there were. Looking over the list now, there are many whose contents entirely escape me. I know I've read them though, so it would be dishonest of me to say otherwise. At the same time, it's almost as if I haven't, for it's not as if having read the ones I've forgotten does me any good except to know I was a completist about that project.

The sad truth is, when reading was long-enough ago, or not terribly memorable to start with, someone who's read a summary of the book would sound more as if they were a reader of it than I. What does it mean to have read a book? Is memory of its contents required for such a claim to be meaningful?
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 9 comments